Monday, May 11, 2009

The Divine Right of Kings vs Vox Populi, Vox Dei

Diane Hsieh at Noodle Food links to this news report regarding a woman who called 911 when her father began having a seizure and ended up in a pissing contest with the policeman handling the call over her use of the 'f' word.

The policeman is obviously a jerk. He priggishly scolded the woman for her initial expletive, even though it was not addressed to him and she had no way of knowing that he would be able to hear it. On the other hand, the woman continued using the expletive even though it was very obviously getting her nowhere with the guy, and meanwhile her father is in a seizure on the floor.

These people strike me as two petty tyrants trying to force their will on each other. The cop, in his position as a public official with the power of life and death over the people who come to him for assistance, has dug in his heels and is going to insist on protocol being followed, regardless of the consequences to the people he is supposed to serve. The woman, as a member of The Public, is insisting on her right to be served patiently and calmly by a public official regardless of how she talks to him, and she is apparently willing to let her father lie on the floor dying while she fights for her right to use the 'f' word.

It's "I'm the government, you have to do what I say" vs "I'm the public, you f-ing owe me."

It's also a symptom of the mixed economy. The entitlements of the welfare state empower government bureaucrats, while privileging certain sections of the population. It's inevitable that the two groups will come into conflict, and this is just one example of something that I'm sure happens every day.

As we move further into the realm of socialism, though, it's the government that will win this contest. When the takeover of the private realm is complete, the priveleged class will find itself enfettered. They will find that "shared sacrifice" includes them too, and whatever scraps they get from the government will come at the expense of being told when to stand, when to sit, and when to shut the hell up.

No comments: